Instacart vs Doordash: Which One Is More Lucrative for Drivers?

When it comes to the world of gig economy, Doordash vs Instacart is a common debate among drivers. Both companies offer opportunities for flexible work and the ability to make money on your own schedule. But which one pays more? As a driver, it’s important to consider the potential earnings and overall benefits of each platform. In this blog post, we’ll delve into the details of Doordash vs Instacart and determine which one is more lucrative for drivers.

Pay Scale: Doordash Vs. Instacart

When it comes to choosing between Doordash and Instacart as a gig economy driver, one of the key factors to consider is the pay scale. After all, making money is the primary reason for joining these platforms. So, which one offers better pay and compensation?

Let’s start by looking at Doordash. As a Doordash driver, you have the opportunity to earn money by delivering food from local restaurants to customers. Doordash operates on a system where you receive a base pay for each delivery, which varies depending on factors like distance and complexity. In addition to the base pay, you also have the potential to earn extra through customer tips. This can significantly boost your earnings if you provide exceptional service.

On the other hand, Instacart is a platform that focuses on grocery delivery. As an Instacart shopper, you help customers with their grocery shopping and deliver their orders to their doorsteps. Similar to Doordash, Instacart provides a base pay for each order. This base pay is determined by factors like the size of the order and the effort required. Additionally, Instacart allows customers to tip, which can add to your overall earnings. 

Both platforms offer opportunities for drivers to increase their income. The general belief is that Instacart shoppers usually get a higher base pay for their orders than Doordash drivers, but Doordash drivers usually get paid much more in tips than Instacart shoppers. And again, this may not be true in your area since it’s important to note that the pay scale can vary depending on factors such as location and demand. In some areas, drivers may find that one platform pays more than the other. It’s crucial to do your research and compare the pay rates in your specific location to make an informed decision. 

Flexibility: Making Money on Your Terms

Flexibility is one of the key advantages of working in the gig economy, and both Doordash and Instacart understand the importance of allowing their drivers to make money on their own terms. Whether you’re looking to work part-time, full-time, or just during specific hours, both platforms offer the flexibility to fit your gig work around your personal commitments and lifestyle.

Let’s start with the hours. With Doordash and Instacart, you have the freedom to choose when you want to work. If you have a busy schedule during the day and prefer to work in the evenings, both platforms accommodate that. Similarly, if you’re only available on weekends, you can still make money by accepting gigs during those times. The flexibility of setting your own hours is especially beneficial if you have another job or responsibilities that require your attention during specific times of the day.

Working in the gig economy also means you have the flexibility to determine how much you want to work. Whether you’re looking to make extra cash on the side or need to rely on gig work as your main source of income, both Doordash and Instacart allow you to choose the number of hours you want to dedicate to driving or shopping. This means you can adjust your workload depending on your financial goals or other commitments in your life.

Another aspect of flexibility that both platforms offer is the ability to work in multiple locations. If you’re someone who likes to travel or often finds yourself in different areas, you can take advantage of the gig economy no matter where you are. Both Doordash and Instacart operate in various cities and regions, giving you the opportunity to make money even when you’re away from your usual location. This flexibility to work in different areas can be a great advantage if you enjoy exploring new places or need to supplement your income while on the go.

In addition to setting your own hours and working in different locations, Doordash and Instacart also provide flexibility in terms of work-life balance. Many drivers appreciate the ability to take time off whenever they need it. If you have personal commitments, vacations, or simply want a break from gig work, you have the freedom to do so. This level of flexibility allows you to prioritize self-care and maintain a healthy work-life balance.

Overall, when it comes to flexibility, both Doordash and Instacart provide opportunities to make money on your own terms. With the ability to set your own hours, work in multiple locations, and prioritize your work-life balance, these platforms offer the flexibility that many gig economy drivers are looking for. Whether you’re a student, a parent, or simply someone who values autonomy in their work, both Doordash and Instacart can provide the flexibility you need to make money on your terms.

Benefits: Perks of the Job

When it comes to working for gig economy platforms like Doordash and Instacart, there are many benefits and perks that drivers can enjoy. Let’s explore some of the advantages that come with these jobs.

First and foremost, one of the major benefits of working for Doordash or Instacart is the flexibility it offers. As a driver, you have the freedom to set your own hours and work when it suits you best. This means you can easily fit your gig work around other commitments in your life, whether it’s another job, family responsibilities, or personal hobbies. This flexibility allows you to have more control over your schedule and create a work-life balance that works for you.

Another perk of working for these platforms is the potential for earning good money. While the pay scale may vary depending on factors like location and demand, both Doordash and Instacart offer opportunities to make decent income. The ability to earn extra through customer tips can significantly boost your earnings. If you provide exceptional service and go above and beyond for your customers, you have the potential to receive generous tips, which can make a significant difference in your overall earnings.

Additionally, working for Doordash or Instacart allows you to explore different areas and neighborhoods. As a driver, you get to visit various parts of your city or region, which can be a fun and interesting experience. If you enjoy exploring new places or simply like driving around and discovering hidden gems, then working for these platforms can be a great way to do so while making money.

Moreover, both Doordash and Instacart provide opportunities for personal growth and development. By working as a driver, you develop valuable skills such as time management, customer service, and problem-solving. These skills can be transferable and beneficial in other areas of your life or future career endeavors. Additionally, interacting with different customers and experiencing diverse situations can help broaden your perspective and enhance your communication skills.

Working for these platforms also offers a sense of independence and autonomy. As a driver, you are your own boss. You have the freedom to choose the orders you want to accept, the hours you want to work, and the locations you want to serve. This level of control and autonomy can be empowering and fulfilling for many drivers. It allows you to work at your own pace, set your own goals, and make decisions that align with your preferences and needs.

Lastly, working for Doordash or Instacart can be a great way to meet new people and build connections. As a driver, you have the opportunity to interact with a variety of customers, restaurant staff, and other drivers. These interactions can lead to meaningful connections and friendships, making your gig work more enjoyable and rewarding.

Challenges: The Other Side of the Coin

The gig economy has its fair share of challenges, and working for Doordash or Instacart is no exception. While there are many benefits to these platforms, it’s important to acknowledge the challenges that drivers may face. Here are some of the potential downsides to consider:

One of the main challenges that drivers face is the unpredictable nature of the job. The gig economy relies heavily on demand, and this can fluctuate greatly depending on factors like time of day, day of the week, and even seasonality. There may be times when there are not enough orders or deliveries available, leading to periods of low earnings. On the other hand, there may be times of high demand where drivers struggle to keep up with the influx of orders. This unpredictability can make it difficult to plan and budget your income, especially if you rely solely on gig work.

Another challenge that drivers may encounter is the physical toll of the job. Both Doordash and Instacart require drivers to spend long hours on their feet, driving, and carrying heavy bags or boxes. This can take a toll on your body, leading to fatigue, muscle strains, and even accidents. It’s important to prioritize your health and well-being by taking breaks, stretching, and practicing good ergonomics. Additionally, drivers are often exposed to various weather conditions, including extreme heat, cold, or rain. This can make the job uncomfortable and challenging, particularly if you don’t have appropriate gear or a vehicle with reliable climate control.

In addition to the physical challenges, drivers may also face issues with customer interactions. While the majority of customers are understanding and appreciative, there may be instances where you encounter difficult or rude individuals. Dealing with unhappy customers or resolving issues can be stressful and time-consuming. It’s important to have strong communication and problem-solving skills to handle these situations effectively. It’s also crucial to remember that as a driver, you represent the platform you work for, so providing excellent customer service is essential.

Lastly, working in the gig economy can be isolating. Unlike traditional jobs where you have colleagues and a structured workplace, gig work often involves working alone and having minimal interaction with others. This lack of social interaction can be challenging for some individuals, particularly those who thrive in team environments. It’s important to find ways to stay connected and maintain a support system, whether it’s through online communities, driver meet-ups, or other means of networking. You also have to file for self-employment tax on your earnings (1099-NEC) for both companies, since you are not an official employee of either company.

In conclusion, while working for Doordash or Instacart comes with its fair share of challenges, many drivers still find it a rewarding and viable option for making money. It’s crucial to be aware of the potential downsides and take steps to mitigate them. By understanding and addressing the challenges, you can navigate the gig economy more effectively and create a successful and fulfilling experience as a driver.

Scroll to Top